Gear
GoPro vs. Insta360 underwater: my switch
- GoPro HERO8 Black
- Insta360 X5
- in use while snorkeling
- whale shark and mantas
In short The Insta360 helps in a crowd because I don't have to aim. The editing takes time, and I'm unhappy with the image quality of my most important shots.
Translated from the German original.
While snorkeling I estimated visibility, water temperature and depth, just as I experienced them on the days I was there. On dives the dive computer measured depth and duration, and values with a named source show what is usual there, not how it was for me.
This post contains affiliate links. The button says where it leads, and right below it says “Advertisement”. If you buy through such a link, I get a small commission. Nothing changes in the price for you.
My GoPro HERO8 Black didn’t survive a dive to twenty meters in Egypt. It was in the water without a case. Since our trip to Mauritius, I have therefore been filming underwater with the Insta360 X5. I haven’t had to aim ever since.
The Insta360 X5 helps me most where you can’t aim, in the whale shark crowd, for example. The editing takes time: for one minute of video, I spend around twenty minutes at the laptop. And I’m unhappy with the image quality of the shots that mattered most to me. I have never compared the two cameras side by side. What is compared here is my old HERO8 Black with the X5; I don’t know newer GoPro models. This is the report of an amateur, not a test.
At a glance
- After the shoot: GoPro: video and photo right away in the finished format. Insta360: two fisheye images, and I only decide on the frame later.
- Aiming: GoPro: necessary, a fish outside the frame is gone. Insta360: not necessary, I follow the animal later at the laptop.
- Editing: GoPro: no cutting needed, but the color still needed post-processing for me. Insta360: around 20 minutes per minute of video (my experience).
- Waterproof without a case to: GoPro HERO8 Black 10 m, Insta360 X5 15 m with the lens guard removed (both according to the manual).
- With a case to: GoPro 60 m with a protective housing (manual). Insta360 50 m with the Pro case, 60 m with the standard one (Insta360 store).
- Color: GoPro: very green-tinged for me. Insta360: a color filter when editing, AquaVision in the app and in Studio.
- My setting: Insta360: 8K, no HDR.
- My verdict: GoPro: finished right away, but you have to aim. Insta360: the concept convinces me, the image quality so far does not.
Contents
- At a glance
- GoPro vs Insta360: which camera suits snorkeling?
- How long does the editing take?
- How waterproof are the GoPro and Insta360 without a case?
- Why does my 360 footage look worse underwater?
- Color: green with the GoPro, filtered in editing with the Insta360
- My settings: 8K, no HDR
- My conclusion
- Frequently asked questions
- Keep reading
GoPro vs Insta360: which camera suits snorkeling?
It was at the whale shark that I realized what the Insta360 can do. On the whale shark tour from Dhigurah, many boats lay close together, all of them there because of one whale shark. Everyone get ready, they said on board, and then: into the water. I simply hold the Insta360 in front of me and look down. There the whale shark swims straight toward me and glides beneath me. Behind it come around fifty snorkelers and ten divers, and everywhere there are fins, hands and arms. I’m not looking at a display; I’m concentrating on swimming.
With the GoPro, I would have had to check in the crowd whether the shark was in the picture. I almost never had a clear view on this tour; usually there was an arm or a snorkeler between me and the animal. Later at the laptop, I chose the frame so that no snorkelers, or only very few, are visible. That doesn’t work with the GoPro.
The GoPro has an advantage, though: videos and photos come out right away in the finished format. I could watch them and send them straight to the family. The price is the aiming. If a fish swims out of the frame, it’s gone. I have some photos and videos from the GoPro in which an animal isn’t fully in the picture or parts of other snorkelers are in the frame. A video like that can’t be saved. The Insta360 lets me follow the fish later in the frame.
I still filmed the manta off Rasdhoo in the Maldives with the GoPro.
In Hanifaru Bay, which we visited from Maalhos in the Maldives, choosing the frame later helped me with the mantas just the same.
Sometimes a recording has more on it than I noticed in the water. You want to film one manta and find out later that there were five others. Then you have those on video too.
How long does the editing take?
No finished video comes out of the Insta360. The camera saves two round fisheye images side by side, like on the cover image of this article. From that, I first cut a normal video at the laptop with the program Insta360 Studio. That takes a while, because I first have to find in the footage what I recorded. I look at the whole 360 degrees, align the image and cut the sequences. Insta360 calls this setting of the frame after the fact reframing. After that, a color filter is added. That’s how the twenty minutes for one minute of video come about.
From one minute of footage I get quite different videos. One time only the animal can be seen. Another time the video starts with the animal and then pans to me. From the 360 degrees, I can also cut a video in a very wide format, a kind of panorama.
Then there is the volume. From the vacation in the Maldives in August, I brought back 379 gigabytes, family videos included. I could also check and cut the videos on my phone while still on vacation. It’s just that you don’t sit down for hours of editing in the evening.
How waterproof are the GoPro and Insta360 without a case?
According to the manual, the X5 is waterproof to 15 meters; the lens guard has to come off first. According to the manual, the HERO8 Black manages 10 meters without a protective housing and up to 60 meters with one.
Still, I always film the X5 in the dive case, even when snorkeling. Without the case, an edge between the images from the two lenses would be visible in the 360-degree video. Insta360 explains this in the manual with the different refractive indices of water and air: when the two images are joined, known as stitching, errors can occur. I have the Invisible Dive Case Pro, which is sealed to 50 meters. The standard dive case goes to 60 meters. Everything else about the case and the camera settings will follow in an article of its own on the X5.
Insta360 dive caseAdvertisement
Why does my 360 footage look worse underwater?
I can only say what went wrong with my shots from the X5. In almost all the shots that mattered to me, the image quality is at its worst.
Worst are the dolphins on Mauritius and the mantas at the cleaning station. There, very many red casts from reflections in the camera case can be seen, and the videos are very bad. The videos of the mantas in Hanifaru Bay and of the whale shark have a red cast too, but not as bad. Maybe it’s because I filmed into the deep blue on a sunny day. That isn’t certain.
With the Pro case, some videos also went wrong. Mostly it was reflections of sunlight, when the light came in at an unfavorable angle. On Insta360’s help pages it says about the Pro case that in strong light a slight, bright arc of light can appear. The manufacturer advises not to film into strong light sources underwater. Unfortunately, I only noticed the reflections at home.
The image quality can certainly be improved. The Insta360 takes practice: you have to take care of the equipment and adjust to every situation. As an amateur filmmaker, I haven’t managed that so far. With more practice, I would certainly stick with the Insta360, if I get around to it.
Color: green with the GoPro, filtered in editing with the Insta360
With the GoPro, a completely different color problem showed up than the red cast of the Insta360 from the case: the colors of my HERO8 were very green-tinged underwater, and without post-processing the videos weren’t that good. Newer GoPro models are said to do this much better; I haven’t tried that.
That water swallows red first is described by the Underwater Photography Guide, a specialist portal for underwater photography: even at a depth of a meter and a half, red is noticeably lost, and at around five meters it has almost disappeared. What counts is the whole path of the light, that is, the depth plus the distance to the subject.
The Insta360 also gets a color filter when editing. For that, Insta360 offers an underwater color correction called AquaVision in the app and in Insta360 Studio. Color remains post-processing with both cameras.
My settings: 8K, no HDR
I filmed the whole Maldives vacation in August in 8K, without HDR. Insta360 recommends 8K at 30 frames per second for good light. According to the manufacturer, the Active HDR function doesn’t work in 8K at all.
My conclusion
I’m thrilled with the concept of the Insta360, but I don’t know yet whether I’ll stick with it. Coming back from vacation with poor image quality is frustrating, and maybe I’ll try a different product. My status today: undecided. I use the camera only once or twice a year. If you decide on the Insta360, plan time for editing and practice with the camera beforehand.
Frequently asked questions
How deep are the X5 and the HERO8 Black waterproof without a case? The X5 to 15 meters; the lens guard has to come off first. The HERO8 Black to 10 meters. Both according to the manufacturer’s manual.
Is the 360-degree camera any good in a crowd? For me, yes: at the whale shark I only had to hold it in front of me and could later leave the other snorkelers out of the frame.
How long does the editing take? Around twenty minutes for one minute of video.
Which setting do I use? 8K without HDR, on the Maldives vacation in August. Insta360 recommends 8K at 30 frames per second for good light.
Keep reading
- Mantas in Hanifaru Bay: the shots that mattered to me
- My first dive in the Red Sea: that is where the still with the Napoleon wrasse was taken
- Rasdhoo: the manta I filmed with the GoPro
- Maalhos: starting point for Hanifaru Bay
- Flic en Flac: the Mauritius trip on which the X5 came along for the first time
- Maldives: all the islands at a glance
- My gear: what else comes along